I’m a southern gal. I’m a Texas girl and quite proud of it. It is the best dang state in the union. Sometimes I imagine my honeymoon including a tour of the State Capitol or a trip to the Alamo. Well, maybe not the honeymoon, but definitely some vacations.
Side-note: A few summers ago the family and I went to Austin for a day in our vacation and we went through the state museum. I lagged behind everyone else the entire way through, enthralled with all things Texas in front of my eyes. I even wanted to try to sneak back in to go through the museum without paying again, but the family vetoed that one. I’m not even sure if I suggested it. They would have vetoed it if I had let them know my secret longings. And then at the Capitol I could hardly stand it I was so enamored. Walking through the halls left me stunned and giddy as a girl on her first date. Every way we walked I had to listen for the footsteps ahead of me to know where I was walking because my eyes were everywhere else. This state-love is another story, though.
If I were to invite you to dinner at my house I would be willing to bet money that I could bait my mother into blessing someone’s heart. Bring up the right kind of character or the proper problem-laden narrative and you’ll strike gold. Usually “Bless her heart,” is the summary statement after a critique of the situation and narrative of the possible solutions. Lest you think I’m being hard on my mother, let me say that I could bring you along for dinner or coffee at a number of other homes and accomplish this same feat. And I’m not criticizing the blessing of others’ hearts. It’s a southern phrase. We’re generally helpful and try to be understanding of others. But there’s a bit of hopelessness in this phrase. We say, “Bless your heart,” but the implicit ending to this phrase is something like, “You just can’t do any better.” Depending on the circumstances we may mean that your intelligence level is hindering you, or your common sense, or your upbringing, or a number of situation influences. Regardless of the reason, we’re blessing your heart because we know things aren’t going to change.
By now you’re probably wondering where politics play into this and why I threw that into the title. If you’re on my wave link you’re probably already thinking about entitlement programs. If not, let me spell it out for you. We’ve all heard the argument that we need more government programs to “get people back on their feet.” But the question is, Have we seen these programs result in people getting back on their feet? I’m not saying there are never people who benefit from forms of welfare and manage to turn around the negative patterns and end up working and supporting themselves and their families. I’m thinking of the general outcome. And beyond that, thinking about whether these forms of aid are conducive to getting people “back on their feet.”
Let me give some examples of what some of this government aid is accomplishing. Good ol’ financial aid for school. I’m not eligible. And honestly, I’m good with that. I like working hard and doing it myself (with the help of family members who have worked hard their entire lives to provide for themselves and me). But here’s what gets me. Back at the JUCO I was sitting in the Student Success Center, I think they called it, waiting for my next class to start and an old friend walks in. I’m glad to see this friend and ask how she is because a lot has transpired since the last time we’d spent time with each other. She tells me having a baby (out of wedlock) really helped her financially. She reports that every penny of her tuition, fees, and books has been covered by financial aid (not scholarships either). I grit my teeth and grin at this. Yes, 25% of my daddy’s income goes to funding this, but maybe it really will benefit her and she’ll be able to provide for her baby in the future. Then she goes on to tell me after financial aid processing is completed she will end up with additional funds. Her plan for these moneys: A $300 paid of Jordans for the baby daddy and a new computer. There’s the problem. That’s not education. What made us think we should pay people for going to school?
Example number two- the income tax refund.
re-fund: to give back or restore (especially money); repay.
According to dictionary.com a refund is giving back money. This would require there originally being a payment of at least the same amount. Last year was my first year to file my own return. It was uneventful, especially since I am still a dependent of my parents and all my deductions were filed on their return because I hadn’t paid in enough to actually benefit from those. In the job I was working at the time I was the go-to girl for advice on filling out W-4s and questions about how to file taxes. FYI- Put Single and 0 on your W-4. Also, you do not have to file as a married person if you are secretly married. Or publicly married for that matter. As this go-to girl I became privy to some irritating information. I learned that one could work a third of the hours I was working (and thus pay less taxes), be the only person working in the marriage, and have a child and get a massive “refund.” I got $67. We’re talking a little more than a tank of gas, here. Other employees were looking at thousands coming in. I was appalled.
Paying people to go to school and giving them tax refunds that come out of the taxes other people are paying in are fabulous incentives to not work. Why even attempt to get a full-time job when you can get your necessities from programs and even swing some spending money at the end? We keep up these programs that enforce the “Bless your heart, [you just can't do any better]” mindset. And it’s working! Not only are we convincing people they can’t do any better, but we are rewarding them such that they don’t even want to try. It’s one thing to pay for someone’s tuition, fees, and books. It’s entirely another to pay for their Jordans and MacBooks. There’s a breakdown in the system when tax dollars begin to be paid out as cash to those who haven’t paid in. It’s ridiculous. If you walked into a department store to return a purchase and the cashier gave the money to the guy behind you, you’d come unglued. I’d pitch a fit. That’s idiotic and unfair. And yet, when we’re blessing people’s hearts, somehow we let it go. Bless your heart programs are no less ridiculous than you getting my money back when I return an item. Think about it. And let it irritate you. We shouldn’t put up with it.
The Government’s Money
23 NovI was walking across campus a couple weeks ago and I happened upon this little gem of liberalism… Let me give you a little context. I didn’t hear the entire thing because I was walking past, but I did hear this girl complain about something she was going to have to do (Your guess is as good as mine. Get a job or file for a loan, maybe.) “because the government won’t give me more money for tuition.” That is exactly what she said. Make sure you read that in your whining ditzy girl voice, too.
I promptly turned around and hit her on top of the head with my umbrella in an effort to knock some sense into her.Okay, so I didn’t have an umbrella. And that’s probably a good thing. But I was seething.Here are some facts about me: I have received no government sponsored financial aid for tuition or books. I have received $3900 in scholarships over my 3 year college career. I will have spent around $15,000 after I pay for this coming semester. That’s not a complaint. This is what I want to do and it has to be paid for. That’s what gets me, though. Higher education is a privilege. None of us deserve it. And since we don’t deserve it, we pay for it. If it were a God-given right it would be free. (e.g. life and liberty) This is the reason property is not considered an inalienable right. The pursuit of property is what we have the right to, not property itself with no pursuit. And this is the problem with the college system today. We have thousands of people convinced that the entirety of education is their inalienable right. Wrong. The pursuit of education should be available to everyone. This means all who work to get an education (including paying for it) deserve one. Those who don’t work for it don’t get it.
I am perfectly aware that this could be me. I could get to a point where I don’t have the resources to continue in my education. When or if that day comes, I will accept that I don’t need or deserve the education unless I can and will pay for it. I don’t have a problem with people delaying the payments until they are out of school granted they actually pay for their education at some point in time. That could be me, too.
One of the many problems with the education entitlement mindset is that it ignores the fact that the government doesn’t have money. Yes, it has revenues (as well as trillions in debt), but those revenues aren’t the same as business revenues. We’re not talking about a company that makes a great product, sells it for a competitive price, and then enjoys the big bucks. We’re talking about mandatory percentages that income earners pay, a percentage on everything we buy, gas taxes, tampon taxes, sin taxes. When you say, “The government won’t give me more money,” you are in essence saying, “The government won’t further drain the taxpayers so that I can have what I want for free.” You feel big and bad when you bash the government because this is 2011 and we’re so over everything. You’re not big and bad. It’s clueless, ignorant. The government has to get its money from somewhere. And please, please don’t suggest they just print more. That’s a problem for another day.
Tags: college, money, taxes